120-unit Glen Cove housing project draws scrutiny over traffic

Posted

A proposal for a 120-unit artment complex near the Glen Street Long Island Rail Road station drew scrutiny at the Glen Cove Planning Board’s meeting onTuesday as board members and residents questioned whether the developer’s traffic study adequately accounted for congestion and future activity at nearby Pascucci Field.
Cedar Swamp Redevelopers LLC is seeking a special-use permit and site plan approval to redevelop the former Retro Fitness property, at 4 Cedar Swamp Road, into a four-story, mixed-use building featuring workforce housing, 1,200 square feet of retail space and public amenities.
During the three-hour meeting, planning board member James Greenberg challenged whether traffic counts collected on two days in April provided an accurate picture of conditions throughout the year.
“I’m just asking over and over again for just an additional study,” Greenberg said. “Because you took two samples in April, and it’s just hard for me to believe that those samples and that data really shows what the impact is on possible development.”
Aaron Machtay, a traffic engineer with VHB, a civil engineering and consulting firm that offers traffic engineering, traffic operations, safety analysis, signal optimization and multimodal transportation planning across the East Coast, defended the study, saying the firm compared traffic conditions with and without the proposed development.

“We’re looking at between 45 and 55 peak-hour trips,” Machtay said, comparing that figure with a 100-trip threshold used in the analysis. “I’m not saying there’s no impact — what I’m saying is there’s no significant impact.” Machtay explained that the projected vehicle trips would be spread across several roads and intersections rather than concentrated at a single location.
Greenberg questioned whether the study adequately accounted for soccer games at nearby Pascucci Field, particularly as the city plans improvements to the facility that could increase its use. The developer has separately proposed approximately 3,600 square feet of parkland improvements in consultation with the city’s Recreation Department.
“You’re adding these units, you’re adding additional people, you’re adding additional visitors,” Greenberg said. “All I’m simply saying is on Saturday, not just that one day in April, but throughout the season.”
Board member Richard Maccarone raised similar concerns. Machtay acknowledged that he lacked projections for future field use, but said he could request the information from the city.
Board Chairman Andrew Kaufman also questioned whether the study accounted for other developments in the area, including a planned $14.9 million expansion at Glen Cove Hospital that he said could bring 500 additional employees by 2029.
Kathleen Deegan Dickson, an attorney for the developer, argued that the property would eventually be redeveloped regardless of whether the apartment proposal moves forward. “It’s going to be redeveloped with a transit-oriented housing project that has support from the Glen Cove Comprehensive Plan update,” Deegan Dickson said, “or it’s going to be redeveloped with something else.”
The 2.3-acre property falls within the city’s Orchard Neighborhood Redevelopment Incentive Overlay District, which encourages transit-oriented development and workforce housing. Under the zoning regulations, the site could accommodate up to 139 apartments.
According to Cedar Swamp Redevelopers’ preliminary rental schedule, the project would include 16 studio units renting for $1,317 to $2,242 per month, 88 one-bedrooms ranging from $1,414 to $2,380, and 15 two-bedrooms ranging from $1,693 to $2,808. Seventy percent of the units would be reserved for households earning between 50 and 80 percent of area median income, with the remaining 30 percent intended for those earning between 80 and 130 percent. The final affordability mix remains subject to state housing agency and lender approval.
The building would have a community room, laundry facilities, a landscaped public plaza and pedestrian connections to the railroad station.
The developer has given the city $500,000 toward a total community-benefits payment of $750,000, to be used at the city’s discretion for municipal needs. The payment is refundable if the project is not approved.
Potential parking challenges generated equally contentious discussion. The developer is proposing 186 parking spaces, including 120 reserved for residents, 24 public spaces south of the railroad tracks and 40 commuter spaces in a newly constructed parking area north of the tracks. The relocated spaces would also serve visitors to Pascucci Field.
Cedar Swamp Redevelopers is also seeking waivers for 74 parking spaces that do not meet zoning requirements, including 54 beneath the building, with a 22-foot-wide access aisle instead of the required 24 feet.
Deegan Dickson emphasized that the development would accommodate its parking demand. “Everybody who has a car will have a parking space in the building or behind the building,” she said. “So there won’t be overflow onto the streets.”
Daniel D., a resident who spoke during the public hearing, said he initially had an open mind about the proposal because of the need for affordable housing, but was disappointed that the presentation did not adequately address existing traffic problems. “I actually came to this meeting very open to this idea,” he said.
He also questioned whether the study reflected conditions residents see during sporting events and peak commuting hours.
Jeanne Jones, a 35-year Glen Cove resident and a regular commuter, said she already struggles to find parking at the Glen Cove LIRR stop, and questioned whether the proposed public spaces neat the Glen Street stop would remain available to commuters. “I’m very worried with the number of spots that are situated in this map,” Jones said.
Vinnie Martinez, who has lived in Glen Cove for 63 years and was a volunteer firefighter for 40 years, said that existing traffic already makes emergency response difficult. “You just can’t get [to emergencies] in the amount of time they really should,” he said.
Martinez also warned that improvements to Pascucci Field could attract additional sports programs and extend periods of heavy traffic.
Not everyone opposed the proposal. Gabor Karsai, the owner of Landmark Realtors Inc. and a former agent for the Cedar Swamp Road property, said he had spent years trying to market the vacant building without securing a commercial tenant or buyer.
“No one took any spaces in there, either office or the gym space, and it didn’t sell, either,” Karsai said.
He argued that industrial or retail development could create its own traffic and parking challenges. “What do we want to do in this spot as Glen Covers?” Karsai asked. “I think this development is probably making the most sense out of the possibilities.”
The public hearing remains open until Dec. 1 as the board continues reviewing the proposal.