Sea Cliff Board of Trustees provides update about progress on 325 Prospect Ave.

Vision for the property is "village-centric, neighborhood-friendly use."

Posted

Sea Cliff Mayor Elena Villafane said that the village will allocate $2,500 for the design of a new septic system at 325 Prospect Ave., Villafane also announced a new nonprofit has been formed to devise a plan to move the property forward.

“This has to be a village centric neighborhood friendly use,” she said. Villafane shared the news during a community meeting attended by around 50 people in village hall on June 16. The new 501(c)(3), The Pump House at Sea Cliff, was created to help facilitate facility agreements between the village and private businesses.

Villafane emphasized that there is a long road ahead and that the village is in the planning stage of a very long process. She shared several developments that happened on the property over the past few years.

“We have had the roof evaluated, repaired and made water proof,” she said. “We have replaced all of the windows and before that we placed the lintels throughout the building.”

The building, also known as the Pumphouse, was constructed in 1941.

It was designed to resemble a residential structure in the colonial revival style. The building served as a diesel pumping station and equipment shed for the Jamaica Water Company.

The village had acquired the property in 2021 for roughly $600,000 as part of Sea Cliff’s settlement with New York American Water following a four-year lawsuit.

The board began taking questions from the crowd, requesting audience members to raise their hands and introduce themselves. A few audience members shouted out questions to the board in the beginning of the meeting about issues such as parking on the property, the use of the land and other issues.

Around 20 residents asked questions about the impact of the building on property values of homes in the village, ways in which the village can keep residents informed about updates regarding the property, the 325 committee, future events on the property and how to stay engaged during the multi-year project.

“Our concern is the impact on our property value and our quality of life by the nature of the events that will be held in this facility over time” Peter Costello, a homeowner on Laurel Avenue said. “When there is not as much public interest in it, that facility becomes something that ruins our neighborhood and ruins our quality of life.” Costello continued, asking the board “what is going to become over time as people gain access to it?”

Villafane explained that the current agreement for the property allows village uses first at no cost, the next use would be a village-related recognized entity such as the Sea Cliff Civic Association or other organizations; the final and “least focused” use would be for private enterprises.

“What we are endeavoring to do is move the building to a place where it's self-sustained financially,” she said. “That it pays its own utilities, that it pays its own insurance, that it will be in charge of the landscaping and the operation.”

Audience reaction throughout the meeting was mixed, with applause for those who praised and criticized the village. Some members accused the village for not doing enough outreach on the project and expressed doubt in the village’s ability to deliver while other members praised village officials and expressed confidence in the future of the endeavor.

While the meeting was contentious at times, disagreements remained civil, with residents and board members alike agreeing that they did want what was best for the property moving forward. One audience member suggested the creation of “a new committee of neighbors that are willing to put time into the property” which received applause from across the room.

The next steps, according to Villafane, is to find an attorney for The Pump House at Sea Cliff and begin looking at possible uses for the space. She added that they are also hoping that the new septic system will be finished so a local event can be held there soon, although she mentioned that the village will not know exactly when the building will be ready.

“Somewhere between now and Aug. 1, I will be contacting you again” she said, adding that if it's not ready by then, she believes “that we're going to push our schedule back, but I will be in contact.”

Catherine Spencer, a 57-year resident of the village, concluded the meeting by expressing her faith in the building's future and her trust in the institutions responsible for its maintenance.

“We've been through a lot of mayors, a lot of board members, and never have we ever had a problem where we didn't trust or believe our government,” the Laurel Avenue resident said. “They have been absolutely wonderful. They cut the taxes low, and so I predict that whatever they follow through with this, you will be feeling secure. We need to feel secure with our government. They will make us feel secure.”