Thursday, October 1, 2026
Babylon’s girls’ soccer team’s incredible 2025 season came to an emotional close with a hard fought 2–1 loss to Cold Spring Harbor in the Long Island Class B championship Nov. 4.
Though the result wasn’t what the Panthers hoped for, the journey was filled with grit, growth, and unforgettable moments.
Led by coach Stuart Love, Babylon captured the Suffolk County Class B title Nov. 1 with a dramatic 1–0 victory over Center Moriches before falling just short of a state playoff berth.
The county championship clinching goal came courtesy of senior captain Lily Krollage, who buried a perfect feed from Emma Muccioli after a brilliant through ball from eighth grader Julianna Colantuono. The final whistle sparked a rush of pure joy, players sprinting to the field, celebrating their county title and the bond that carried them there.
Love reflected on the bittersweet ending with pride and perspective. “We have mixed feelings,” he said. “Of course, we’re disappointed to lose the Long Island championship, but winning the county final and having that moment together, rushing the field, was something really special. This group earned that.”
Leadership defined the Panthers. After finishing the regular season with a record of 7-6-3, there were a lot of ups and downs but led by senior captains Alexa Casale and Lily Krollage, the tone was set. Alongside eight other seniors, they built a culture of accountability and mentorship that elevated the entire team.
“We had ten seniors who all showed great leadership,” Love said. “They really took the younger players under their wing and helped build the foundation for the future.”
That guidance paid off in some of Babylon’s biggest moments. The defense, anchored by junior goalkeeper Gianna Durler, had a huge impact on the team's success. Durler made a series of crucial saves, supported by defenders Carissa Arena, Katie Bellone, and Alex Esposito, who tirelessly shut down opposing attacks. Sofia Giorgio also stood out for her ability to neutralize opponents’ fastest forwards.
In the midfield, Delaney Busch served as the engine, her ability to connect the lines was instrumental in keeping Babylon in the game against high pressure teams.
In the Long Island championship game, the Panthers battled with heart from start to finish. Alexa Casale scored Babylon’s lone goal, giving her team hope and momentum, but Cold Spring Harbor ultimately prevailed. Still, Love praised his players for their relentless effort. “For long stretches, we outplayed the opposition. I couldn’t be prouder.”
For the seniors, their final season was about more than soccer. It was about friendship, leadership, and leaving a lasting legacy. They’ve set a standard, one goal, one save, one championship moment at a time, that the next generation of Panthers is ready to carry forward.
With standouts like Durler, Muccioli, and Colantuono returning, the Panthers’ future is bright. “The returning group is going to be very motivated in 2026,” Love said. “The foundation is strong, the future is bright for sure.”
