Thursday, October 1, 2026
For 16 seasons, coach Colleen Kilgus has led the West Babylon girls’ lacrosse team with passion, consistency, and a deep love for the game. Her dedication to the program has not only developed top-tier athletes but also cultivated a close-knit community where players stay connected long after they graduate.
“I still speak to girls I coached 16 years ago,” Kilgus says, reflecting on the lasting bonds forged through the sport. That sense of family continues to be the heartbeat of this year’s group.
This season, the Eagles are packed with standout talent and undeniable chemistry. Leading the way is Avery Vergano, a five-year player and senior heading to play at the Division I level at Cincinnati next year. Avery’s leadership and grit set the tone both on and off the field. “She’s a coach’s dream,” Kilgus says. “She leads by example, she’s tough, and she brings the team together.”
Another returning top talent is Giavanna Coldanato, a junior who has been at the varsity level since middle school. “She has tons of experience,” Kilgus said. “She has been a part of our team since middle school and her comeback from injury last season has energized us. She’s the kind of player who changes the game the second she steps on the field.”
In goal, the Eagles have two major assets. According to Kilgus, senior Charlotte Bilicki has emerged as one of the top goalies in Suffolk County, known for her quick reflexes and fearless play. Alongside her is junior Victoria Pelliccione, a versatile player who’s stepped into the goalie position when needed. “Victoria can really do it all,” Kilgus adds. “We’re lucky to have that kind of flexibility.”
Offensively, the Eagles are a threat from all angles. Lindsey Olivar, a lefty attacker, adds a dynamic edge to their offense, while Emily Paolillo has become one of the top attackers in the region, constantly drawing double teams and still finding ways to score. “Emily has such a natural feel for the game,” Kilgus says. “She’s one of the most creative players we’ve had.”
Holding down the defense is Chloe Downey, one of the Eagles’ top defenders. Her instincts, speed, and ability to read the offense make her a cornerstone of the Eagles’ back line. “Chloe gives us stability and strength,” Kilgus says. “She makes everyone around her better.”
West Babylon has had a roller coaster season so far. After starting the season 3-0, thanks to wins over Lindenhurst, Southampton, and Glenn, the Eagles lost three straight to fall back to .500 but have since defeated Hauppauge 12-3. Leading the way in scoring was Avery Vergano with five goals. Emily Paolillo and freshman Ella Stuart also contributed offensively with two goals each.
With a core of veterans, rising young stars, and a coach who’s built a legacy of mentorship and pride, the West Babylon Eagles girls lacrosse team is more than ready for whatever comes next. Kilgus has noticed the steps in the right direction that they are taking. “Being with the girls at practice is my favorite part about this,” she said. “I just love watching them progress.”
