Residents of Valley Stream’s Mill Brook neighborhood say the construction of increasingly large homes is changing the character of their community, raising concerns about flooding, drainage, aging infrastructure and housing affordability.
A petition from the Mill Brook and Parkhurst civic associations urges the Hempstead Town Board to address the impact of large-scale residential redevelopment, and to ensure that new construction respects established neighborhood character and accounts for environmental concerns, particularly street flooding.
Beth Ward, who has lived in Millbrook since 1998, said the neighborhood was designed as a planned community with green space connecting residential blocks. The original development incorporated cul-de-sacs ending at entrances to green spaces, while a wooded area between the older and newer sections allowed schoolchildren and other pedestrians to walk between them, she said.
Ward said she is particularly concerned about the loss of permeable ground as larger homes replace more modest properties. She said the front areas of newly built homes are often completely paved, leaving little room for vegetation to absorb rainwater.
“All of the McMansions that have been built in our development have a totally paved over front area,” Ward wrote. “It cannot be called a yard, because there is no earth or anything growing.”
Ward said the removal of trees during construction further reduces the amount of vegetation in the neighborhood.
“Where is the rain or flood water to go with no roots to drink it up?” she wrote.
Ward said many parts of the neighborhood are in a Federal Emergency Management Agency-designated flood zone, requiring some residents to purchase flood insurance. She also pointed to the neighborhood’s aging sewer system, which she said dates to 1939, as a concern.
The neighborhood’s stream path was renovated in 2019 with grant funding, Ward said, adding that she remains concerned about how additional pavement could affect an area already prone to flooding.
“Changing the look, feel, or economics of a neighborhood is one thing; destroying its infrastructure is quite another,” Ward wrote.
In a Facebook post, the Mill Brook Civic Association described concerns about homes of roughly 4,000 square feet replacing more modest houses of about 1,200 square feet.
Guillermo VanEtten, president of the association, said the construction has reduced green space and increased the amount of property covered by pavement. He also said additional driveways have raised concerns about street parking, particularly near an elementary school.
VanEtten said the neighborhood dates to the 1930s and that residents are concerned about whether its existing infrastructure can accommodate the changes.
“The infrastructure already that we have is so old,” he said.
He also cited drainage and flooding as concerns, saying residents have dealt with flooding problems since Superstorm Sandy in 2012.
Residents want officials to examine whether drainage systems, sewer lines and other public infrastructure can accommodate the scale of new construction, VanEtten said.
The size and cost of the new homes have also prompted concerns about affordability and whether longtime residents and younger families will be able to remain in the community. VanEtten said the trend could make it harder for people who grew up in the neighborhood to purchase homes nearby or for older residents to downsize without leaving the area.
“We have our legislators, we have our politicians … always showing concern about affordability,” VanEtten said. “I mean, this is like a double-edged sword here. How you talk about affordability, and we're allowing this to happen.”
VanEtten said residents are not opposed to new construction but want development to respect the needs of the existing community.
He said he has been raising concerns with the Town of Hempstead for more than a year. Residents attended a Town Board meeting in September, met with Building Commissioner Daniel Leo and shared photographs of construction conditions, he said.
Michael Belfiore, a Valley Stream resident who also raised questions about area development, said residents should examine how the homes received approval and whether existing zoning requirements adequately address their size.
In Elmont, residents of the Parkhurst neighborhood have raised similar concerns about development.
In an interview with the Herald, Aubrey Philip, president of the Parkhurst Civic Association, and Lori Hallop, the association’s vice president, discussed concerns about oversized homes under construction and the overnight parking of commercial vehicles.
Philip questioned the town’s regulations governing additions and alterations, including a provision allowing work “in excess of 50%.” He also raised questions about lot coverage, setbacks from roads and neighboring properties, and how square footage is calculated.
The civic association is seeking a townwide moratorium on construction of oversized homes while town officials review and clarify building regulations. The group is also calling for stronger inspections, community notice and enforcement.
Residents and civic groups in Elmont, Millbrook and North Valley Stream have contacted town officials about their concerns, but described the responses as limited.
The Parkhurst association also raised concerns about commercial vehicles parked overnight on residential streets. Philip said business owners should find commercial space to store their vehicles rather than leaving them in residential neighborhoods.
Brian Devine, the Town of Hempstead’s director of communications, responded to the concerns by email. He said the town is aware of residents’ concerns and that, like most of the town, Elmont is in the Residence B zoning district, which limits dwelling size to 27.5% of the lot area.
Devine said the Nassau County Police Department handles street-parking violations. He urged residents to report suspected zoning violations to the Town of Hempstead Building Department at (516) 538-8500.
The town’s Building Department oversees building permits and enforcement of applicable building codes and local regulations. The Board of Appeals reviews certain disputes involving building permits and applications for zoning variances and special exceptions.
The Mill Brook and Parkhurst civic associations have encouraged residents to sign its petition and share photographs of construction projects or conditions they believe warrant further review. Both civic groups want town officials to address residents’ concerns about how redevelopment affects established neighborhoods.