Monday, May 19, 2025
A 20-year-old assistant boys lacrosse coach at Valley Stream Central High School has been arrested on federal charges for allegedly coercing a 13-year-old boy into sending sexually explicit images over Snapchat, part of what authorities describe as a wider pattern of abuse involving at least 30 boys.
Joseph Garofalo, of Valley Stream, was charged with the sexual exploitation of children and pleaded not guilty in federal court last month. He remains in custody after a judge denied bail, citing Garofalo’s own admission of a long-standing “addiction” to such behavior and the scope of evidence found on his devices.
According to prosecutors, the FBI has so far identified 30 victims—most from Long Island—after reviewing just a fraction of the data on four phones seized from Garofalo’s home. Court documents reveal that Garofalo allegedly used Snapchat to pressure the 13-year-old, threatening to release the explicit material unless more was sent.
In one exchange, Garofalo reportedly demanded images of the boy’s friends in exchange for deleting prior content. “Send stuff of ur boys naked n il delete,” one message read.
Garofalo’s attorney, Anthony La Pinta, called the charges “a shock” to the family, adding they remain “unconditionally supportive” of him.
Valley Stream Central High School District Superintendent Wayne Loper confirmed Garofalo is no longer with the district and said the FBI assured officials that no district students were among the alleged victims.
“We have been in contact with investigators from the Federal Bureau of Investigation, who have advised that none of the allegations against this individual involve Valley Stream Central High School District students,” said Loper in a statement to parents.
“As with all individuals working in our schools, this former coach underwent mandated state and federal background checks prior to his employment by the District and cleared all vetting procedures. We recognize that this news is extremely disturbing, and we appreciate your understanding. The safety and well-being of our students remains our utmost commitment.”
The FBI is urging any potential victims to contact them at (1-800) 225-5324.
