I’m the father of three. My son is 21 and my daughters are 10 and 7, so I know I’ll be having certain conversations again soon. When it was my son’s turn, I talked to him about the risks of substance abuse. He knew not to get in a car with someone who had been drinking, and he knew he could call me at any hour and I would answer without judgment.
What surprised me was how little I knew about the rules that apply to parents here. I suspect I’m not alone, so I’m sharing what I’ve learned.
Nassau County has had a Social Host Law since 2007. It is illegal for anyone over 18 who owns, rents or controls a home to permit drinking by minors at a gathering there, if they are present and aware of it. According to the district attorney’s office, which helped develop the law, a violation can mean a misdemeanor conviction, and repeat offenders can face up to a year in jail.
Three things got my attention. First, a party can get away from even well-meaning hosts. In 2016, police in Great Neck found about 400 people, most of them underage, at a home. The homeowner received an appearance ticket.
The family’s attorney told a different story: The kids arrived drunk, there was no alcohol in the house, and the homeowner himself called police. I don’t know where the truth lies. What struck me is how ordinarily the incident began. According to the family, it was a small get-together for their 16-year-old daughter, and word spread on social media. Any parent of a teenager can picture that.
Second, the law doesn’t only apply to parents. In Long Beach, police issued a summons to a 19-year-old after finding 150 to 200 underage people drinking and the parents believed to be away. Parents who aren’t home and don’t know about the drinking aren’t liable, but an 18-year-old left home alone for the weekend can be.
Third, “I didn’t know” isn’t a guaranteed defense. Lawyers call it willful blindness: When someone suspects something and deliberately avoids confirming it, a court or jury can treat that as knowing. The federal appeals court covering New York has described it that way. I’m not a lawyer, and I haven’t found a Nassau case applying the idea to the Social Host Law, but the law turns on whether an adult who is home is aware. Hearing a houseful of teenagers and choosing not to check may not hold up.
Parents are often in the loop, too. In a California study of teens who hosted parties with alcohol, 70 percent said that at least one parent knew guests under 21 were drinking, and another 24 percent said their parents probably knew.
None of this is meant to judge anyone. Many of us tell ourselves that a party at our house is safer than one somewhere else, and I’ve felt that instinct. But supervision doesn’t stop a teenager from driving home afterward, and a gathering can outgrow its plan quickly.
The stakes are real. When the law passed, county legislators cited local surveys in which 70 percent of high school seniors reported drinking at parties in homes. Research on whether laws like this change behavior is mixed, but awareness is something we can all control.
Talk about the law, not just the rule. “This can end in a criminal charge” lands better than “because I said so.”
Know where your kids are going. Call the other parent. It’s awkward, but it works.
Plan for parties that grow. Tell your kids to call you if a gathering gets bigger than planned, and you’ll help without a lecture that night.
Keep the door open. A ride home at any hour, no questions asked, is the best safety net we have.
Be clear with older teens. At 18, they are legally responsible for what happens in their house.
Talk to other parents. Most of us only learn this after something goes wrong. It’s better to hear it from a neighbor first.
I don’t have all the answers, and I’m sure I’ll make mistakes with my daughters, too. But I’d rather be a parent who knew the rules than one who found out too late.
Sean D. Trager is co-president of the North Shore Coalition Against Substance Abuse.