A federal judge has ruled in favor of the Freeport school district in a civil lawsuit filed by a former employee against the district and some of its administrators. Former school psychologist Elizabeth D’Aiello claimed that a colleague had racially discriminated against her by calling her “Karen,” and that the school district had improperly protected her colleague.
D’Aiello worked at Freeport High School from February 2004 until she resigned in 2024. The suit alleged that on Nov. 9, 2021, when D’Aiello and guidance counselor Melissa McCormack entered the office of Assistant Principal Aaron Johnson, Johnson’s secretary, Tondra Jackson, said, “Here comes Karen one and Karen two.”
Calling someone a “Karen” has been popularized as a way to refer to a woman, typically white, who is seen as demanding, rude or racist. The term is considered by many to be insulting, sexist and discriminatory. D’Aiello and McCormack are white; Jackson is Black.
D’Aiello claimed in the suit that Jackson’s comments were racially discriminatory, but Joan M. Azrack, a U.S. District Judge for the Eastern District of New York, disagreed and dismissed her claim on Oct. 20. In her ruling, Azrack, who is also white, wrote that although the remark may have been “unpleasant” for D’Aiello, there was no proof of any adverse effect on her employment.
Azrack remanded the case back to State Supreme Court in Brooklyn, where D’Aiello will continue to pursue her claims, according to her attorney, Vincent Miletti. The return date for the case, Miletti said, is Feb. 17, 2027, and he expects a decision two to four months after that.
“The New York state human rights law… gets more and more liberal every single year,” Miletti said. “The standard is someone just needs to be alleging that they were treated less well than someone else, and all facts go to the jury.”
Miletti added that the “chaos” in the Freeport school district and perceived deficiencies in leadership, leading to a high turnover rate, will cast a favorable light on D’Aiello’s claim. He said that Azrack “created awful precedent” by not allowing a jury to hear the case and not thoroughly considering the grievance.
“When the judge comes in and wants to just refuse to let things go to the jury — legitimate questions of fact — you are taking the whole system and perverting it upside down,” Miletti told the Herald.
Miletti said that D’Aiello had tried to address her concerns through the Freeport Teachers Association, but was unable to make any headway. He added that Benjamin Roberts, a former assistant superintendent, largely ignored D’Aiello’s concerns.
Roberts, who is now superintendent of the Tuckahoe school district in Eastchester, did not respond to a request for comment. Patricia Langan, the teachers association president, initially said she was willing to answer the Herald’s questions, but did not do so before press time. According to court documents, Langan had previously said that the “Karen” comment was sexist and “could be perceived as racist.”
In her December 2024 resignation letter, almost two years after she filed the lawsuit against the district on Jan. 9, 2023, D’Aiello wrote that she felt that she was being ignored. She now works for the U.S. Department of Education in Brooklyn, for a significantly smaller salary than she had in Freeport, according to Miletti.
The case’s summary judgment stated that although D’Aiello did not hear the “Karen” comment in the 2021 meeting, McCormack did, and later told D’Aiello. The pair talked with another assistant principal, Wendy Haise, later that day, and the discussion eventually involved Principal Giselle Campbell-Ham and Langan.
Ten days after the incident, according to court documents, Campbell-Ham arranged a meeting involving D’Aiello, McCormack, Johnson, Langan and Jackson, overseen by Haise. D’Aiello testified in a deposition that during that meeting, Jackson made fun of her, which she believed was related to a hearing disability she has.
After apologizing for her behavior, Jackson left the meeting, and the remaining participants continued to discuss the term “Karen.” According to deposition testimony, the meeting devolved into a spat of insults, yelling and confusion, as Johnson, who is black and is a diversity, equity and inclusion specialist, touted his status as a “scholar” on race.
According to D’Aiello, Johnson at one point told her, “This is not fairyland, Ms. D’Aiello, this is Freeport,” a comment she interpreted as racially discriminatory. Fairyland Park, an amusement park in Kansas City that closed in 1977, was known for its racial segregation.
Johnson did not respond to a request for comment.
A subsequent investigation by the district, including Campbell-Ham and Assistant Superintendent Alice Kane, concluded that while Johnson’s conduct was unprofessional, it “did not rise to the level of harassment,” and that Jackson had adequately apologized for her earlier comments.
D’Aiello’s interactions with Johnson from that point on were minimal before he resigned in October 2024. Still, in her suit, she alleged that there were moments in which Johnson acted aggressively, making her anxious. She also claimed that instances in which her work-related requests were delayed or denied suggests adverse treatment by the district.
Citing Title VII civil rights violations, D’Aiello initially filed the suit in State Supreme Court, naming the school district, Freeport High School, Campbell-Ham, Johnson, Jackson and Kishore Kuncham, the district superintendent at the time. The state court referred the case to the Eastern District court. Jackson was later removed as a defendant.
Azrack ruled that there was no evidence supporting D’Aiello’s claims of unlawful employment practice and discrimination. The judge concluded that D’Aiello had not suffered any retaliation for her complaint, and that the alleged “harassment” she suffered was unprofessional, but not discriminatory.
Miletti argues that Azrack overlooked viable evidence. One example he gave was a recorded phone conversation between Johnson Kane, in which Kane allegedly said that the district had to just “get over this,” referring to D’Aiello’s complaints — an indication, Miletti said, that the school district was not taking those complaints seriously.
Azrack did not respond to a request for comment.
In a statement from the Board of Education, the district said that it was satisfied with the outcome of the case.
“We appreciate the current controversy over the term and its various slang interpretations,” the statement read, referring to “Karen,” “and understand the term might be interpreted in different ways given the particular circumstances, the individuals involved and the intent behind the use of the term. Ultimately, no one should have to tolerate discrimination or harassment. Freeport policies prohibit such behavior and provide procedures for reporting and resolving complaints.”