Herald editorial

We can’t afford to gamble with our water

Posted

Long Island is surrounded by water. Rivers, lakes, ponds and streams weave through its communities, shaping its landscape, supporting its wildlife and providing places for recreation.

Yet the most important water resource beneath our feet — the sole-source aquifer that supplies drinking water to nearly 3 million people — remains vulnerable to contamination, inconsistent oversight and a patchwork of protections.

Clean, safe drinking water is not a luxury, it is a basic necessity. And protecting it should be among the highest priorities of every level of government, not a responsibility divided among dozens of agencies, municipalities and private water providers that too often operate independently. Long Island needs a coordinated approach.

On Nov. 9, the Suffolk County Water Authority announced a $1.68 million grant to extend public water service to 60 Mattituck homes affected by PFAS contamination. These are the so-called “forever chemicals” that do not break down and persist in threatening people and animals.

The money was welcome news for those homeowners, but it also raises a larger question: Why should families have to wait for contamination to threaten their drinking water before meaningful protections and assistance arrive?

Even the cost of obtaining safe water is becoming a concern. Liberty Water customers in Nassau County face proposed monthly increases of $21 to $28. While water infrastructure requires investment and maintenance, affordability must remain part of the equation, too. Families should not have to choose between paying their water bills and buying bottled water because they’ve lost confidence in what comes out of their taps.

The problem extends beyond individual neighborhoods. According to a study conducted by the Environment America Research & Policy Center, New York Public Interest Research Group and Frontier Group, more than one-third of Nassau and Suffolk school buildings had at least one drinking or cooking water fixture that exceeded the state’s lead standard. Children should never have to wonder whether the water coming from a school fountain or kitchen faucet is safe.

In Suffolk, the Town of Brookhaven’s proposed landfill cleanup plan has drawn criticism from the state Department of Environmental Conservation, and the expansion of battery storage facilities has generated additional concerns about potential groundwater contamination. These are not isolated issues. Pollutants are not bound by municipal borders as they seep into the water supply miles from their starting point.

The current system is too fragmented for a challenge this consequential. The counties, local governments, the state, water authorities and private providers all have roles to play. But responsibility without coordination invites gaps in oversight, inconsistent standards and delayed action. As we have seen with underground toxic plumes, contamination doesn’t stop at a town line.

Long Island and Albany have spent over a decade building multi-agency frameworks to protect and preserve the Island’s sole-source aquifer system. But the debate over whether those bodies have enough regulatory enforcement power appears to be the obstacle.

Leaders from Albany must take a major role in ensuring enforcement. That means dedicating state funding to modernizing aging infrastructure, remediating contaminated sites and extending safe public water service to affected neighborhoods.Local governments and water providers must be equally accountable, sharing information and working toward common standards rather than treating water protection as someone else’s responsibility.

We can’t afford to wait for the next contamination discovery, another school testing failure or another neighborhood forced to use bottled water. Prevention is less costly, financially, environmentally and health-wise, than remediation after the damage is done.

Long Island’s water is a shared resource, and protecting it is a shared obligation. A homeowner’s ZIP code, income or choice of water provider should never determine whether the water flowing into a home is safe to drink.

We have an extraordinary natural resource beneath our feet and all around us. It’s time our commitment to protecting it reflected just how much it matters.