“It wasn’t sadness,” Rabbi Jack Zanerhaft, from Temple Emanu-El of the South Shore, said reflecting on the temple’s merger. “But a new Jewish community of sorts that was coming together, and there was strength and happiness.”
In 2023, Temple Emanu-El of Long Beach and the South Shore Jewish Center, in Island Park made the decision to merge. In the next year or so, they followed state supreme court requirements — their approval as well as a vote by both congregations — and were formally approved by the state in September 2025, just before Rosh Hashana.
Much like its cross-bay neighbor, South Shore Jewish Center was a staple in the community. Established in 1952, its annual events included a dinner for Shabbat Across America in March, Shabbat on the Beach at Masone Beach in August; a luncheon on the second day of Rosh Hashana; Thanksgiving interfaith services and Hanukkah menorah lighting on the Island Park Village Green, between George Street and Tibbits Avenue.
The merger was unique. The Jewish Center, a conservative synagogue and the temple a reform denomination, presented a unique challenge for the merged temple’s two-dozen plus board, which represents both former bodies.
Yvette Oppenheim, president of Temple Emanu-El of the South Shore, said they aimed to bridge the tension by holding meet-and-greets, which were successful. Zanerhaft said they hosted Friday, and Saturday services to accommodate both denominations, and even use the Jewish Center’s original torahs, prayer books and incantations.
“The new congregants are very happy to participate in a lot of the events that we have had,” Oppenheim said. “It’s a very warm environment because everyone knows each other.”
Lisa Arian, a past president of the South Shore Jewish Center, and current congregant, wrote in a text message that everyone was delighted to celebrate the anniversary. Arian said the newly named congregation of Temple Emanu-El meets the goal of supplying both the religious and social needs of the former congregations.
“Attendance has increased at both services, and both the sisterhood and brotherhood have had even more participants,” Arian wrote. “The new friendships that have come abound and the respect for each other’s differences have created this warmth that’s delightful to all.”
As Zanerhaft reflected on the merger, he remembered the two dozen temple members that came together last fall, who marched from East Market Street in Long Beach to the combined synagogues’ new home — Temple Emanu-El of the South Shore, on Neptune Boulevard — with Four Jewish Center torahs in hand.
“We understood the emotional challenge, the sense of uprootedness, of a community leaving their sacred house of worship that was in place for decades,” Zanerhaft said. “To be able to have the familiarity in a new physical space, I think it was very important for the torahs to play that role.”