Sponsored content: Natalie Smith

What luxury homebuyers really want on Long Island today

Posted

For luxury homebuyers on Long Island, a high price tag doesn't necessarily mean a property has everything they're looking for. Buyers are placing a premium on updated homes, privacy and outdoor space, along with the convenience of staying connected to Manhattan.

“Today's luxury buyers are prioritizing move-in-ready homes, quality renovations, outdoor space and convenience,” said Natalie Smith, a licensed real estate salesperson with The Colombos-Dooley Team.

Smith said buyers are looking more closely at how a home will work for them day to day. And on Long Island, where luxury can mean something different from one community to the next, the right property often comes down to more than its asking price.

What defines luxury on Long Island?

“Luxury real estate is really defined by the market you're in,” Smith said.

The National Association of Realtors generally identifies luxury properties as those within the top 10 percent of a local market by price, Smith said. While New York's $1 million mansion tax threshold is often associated with luxury, she cautions that it doesn't necessarily define a luxury property.

A $1 million home may be considered a premium property in one neighborhood, while luxury pricing in Manhasset, Old Westbury or Sands Point can begin considerably higher.

Smith said buyers need to consider the community, property size, architecture and amenities when evaluating what makes a home luxurious.

Why move-in-ready homes are in demand

One of the strongest preferences Smith is seeing is for homes that don't require major renovations after closing.

Modern kitchens, updated bathrooms and flexible living spaces are particularly appealing, along with outdoor areas that have already been well maintained.

Smith said many luxury buyers want the convenience of moving into a home without immediately having to oversee extensive improvements.

That doesn't mean older properties have fallen out of favor. Long Island's historic Gold Coast estates continue to attract buyers who appreciate their craftsmanship, architectural details, mature landscaping and expansive grounds.

“These properties often offer extraordinary craftsmanship, mature landscaping, expansive grounds and architectural details that are difficult to reproduce in newer construction,” Smith said.

But buyers considering those estates also need to account for renovation expenses, timelines and the challenges that can come with updating an older home.

Different communities appeal to different buyers

Smith said Manhasset, Garden City, Old Westbury and Sands Point remain among Long Island's most desirable luxury markets, although buyers are drawn to each for different reasons.

Manhasset appeals to those who want an upscale suburban lifestyle with convenient access to Manhattan. Garden City offers established residential neighborhoods and village charm.

Old Westbury attracts buyers looking for expansive estates, acreage and privacy, while Sands Point is particularly appealing for its waterfront properties and Gold Coast setting.

Recent market figures help illustrate the differences. A Nassau County market overview reported Manhasset's average sold price at approximately $2.25 million as of October 2026, while Old Westbury's median home value was approximately $3.08 million.

For buyers relocating from New York City, Smith said the ability to gain more living space without losing access to Manhattan remains a significant consideration.

“One of the trends I'm seeing is buyers who want more living space, privacy and outdoor amenities without giving up their connection to Manhattan,” Smith said.

She is also seeing buyers consider Long Island for second homes and weekend retreats, rather than exclusively for primary residences.

“Ultimately, luxury buyers are looking beyond the home itself. They're evaluating how the property complements their lifestyle, from commuting and entertaining to privacy and everyday convenience,” Smith said.

Why pricing matters in a competitive market

Despite continued interest in luxury properties, Smith said sellers shouldn't assume a desirable address or impressive home will automatically attract a buyer.

“Pricing is the single most important factor,” Smith said.

Luxury buyers are comparing properties carefully, paying close attention to condition, location and amenities. Even a beautifully renovated home can sit on the market if its asking price exceeds what buyers believe it is worth.

Smith said professional photography, thoughtful staging and targeted marketing can help attract qualified buyers, but those efforts need to be supported by a competitive listing price.

Her approach involves reviewing comparable sales, current inventory and buyer behavior to determine how a property should be positioned.

What's ahead for Long Island luxury homes?

Looking toward 2027, Smith remains cautiously optimistic about Long Island's luxury market. Established communities, desirable locations and limited housing supply continue to support demand, she said, although interest rates and broader economic conditions could influence pricing.

“I anticipate that well-positioned luxury homes in desirable communities will continue to attract serious buyers,” Smith said.

She expects buyers to remain selective, making accurate pricing and property conditions increasingly important.

The direction of the market reinforces what Smith's already seeing among buyers: Luxury isn't simply about spending more. It's about finding a property that offers the location, convenience and lifestyle they're looking for.


Herald Content Studio articles are produced by the Herald’s marketing division and independent of the newsroom. The Herald may be compensated by featured companies or purchases made through these articles, which does not constitute the Herald’s endorsement.