Island Park Library readers gravitated toward suspense-filled thrillers and emotionally driven novels in 2025, according to annual circulation data. Bestselling authors dominated the library’s most checked-out books of the year and gripping storylines, reflecting a strong community interest in fast-paced plots and character-centered narratives. The top five titles offer a snapshot of the stories that kept Island Park readers turning pages throughout the year.
No. 1: "The Crash" by Freida McFadden
Topping the list as the most checked-out book of 2025 was “The Crash” by Freida McFadden, a fast-paced psychological thriller that kept readers guessing until the final pages. The novel follows a woman, Tegan, who survives a devastating car accident while eight months pregnant only to find herself trapped in a remote house under the care of a couple whose intentions quickly come into question. The book’s relentless suspect and short, binge-worthy chapters made it a standout favorite among Island Park readers.
No. 2: "The Tenant" by Freida McFadden
Claiming the second spot is another McFadden thriller, “The Tenant.” The story centers on Blake Porter, who rents out a room in his apartment, only to realize that his new tenant may not be who she claims to be. What begins as an uneasy living arrangement spirals into a dangerous psychological game filled with manipulation and unexpected twists. Island Park readers were drawn to the novel’s claustrophobic tension and McFadden’s ability to turn ordinary situations into chilling scenarios.
No. 3: "The Wedding People" by Alison Espach
“The Wedding People” by Alison Espach is a novel that blends humor, heartbreak and self-discovery. The book follows a woman, Phoebe, who unexpectedly finds herself entangled in a wedding weekend at a luxurious hotel during a deeply vulnerable moment in her life. Through sharp dialogue and emotional depth, Espach explores themes of grief, loneliness, connection and the strange ways strangers can change one another.
No. 4: "Never Say Never" by Danielle Steel
Danielle Steel’s “Never Say Never” follows a successful woman navigating love, career and personal reinvention later in life. As she confronts unexpected challenges and second chances, Steel weaves a tale about resilience, courage and the possibility of new beginnings at any age. The novel’s uplifting message and emotional warmth resonated strongly with Island Park readers.
No. 5: "The Women" by Kristin Hannah
Rounding out the top five is “The Women” by Kristin Hannah, a powerful historical novel that shines a light on the often-overlooked experiences of women who served as nurses during the Vietnam War. Through the journey of Frances “Frankie” McGrath, the novel explores friendship, trauma and the lasting effects of war both abroad and at home.
