Columnist

Daniel Rehman: Teaching students when not to ask the machine

Posted

In a world full of nonstop information, opinions and media, algorithms can quietly manipulate our choices and preferences. The world is changing fast. Are we teaching our students how to navigate it, or just how to survive school?

In West Hempstead, as in districts across the country, we have seen a clear rise in the number of students using artificial intelligence tools. Our staff is divided. Some want to ban A.I. for students. Others want to leave it alone. A few have simply shrugged. I understand all three reactions, but none of them is a plan.

I am not anti-technology in education. I have, however, become more skeptical about what I will accept. The question I keep asking is about return on learning: What do students actually gain? A.I. can be a powerful tool, but students need to learn how to use it well. That includes knowing when, and why, not to use it.

Here is my concern: Learning is messy and rarely moves in a straight line. It depends on questions, and good questions take time to form. Think of our youngest learners, who run into school asking question after question. Better yet, think of your own children in their early years.

Most of those questions didn’t get answered by a lookup. They got answered through conversation, back and forth, with someone who cared. When answers, summaries and research arrive instantly, I worry that the desire to ask questions will fade.

This worry is older than any algorithm. In “Phaedrus,” Plato has Socrates warn that the new technology of writing would weaken memory and give people the appearance of wisdom rather than the real thing. In his “Seventh Letter,” Plato explains why he never wrote down his deepest ideas. True understanding can’t be contained in a text. It comes only after long, shared effort between teacher and student, until a spark finally catches and burns on its own.

The educational scholar Seymour Sarason made a similar point: “Learning occurs in an interpersonal context and is dynamically comprised of factors whose sum is never zero. These factors have labels such as motivation, attitude, cognition, affect, and self-regard.” Put simply, learning is never just about information. It is about relationships, emotions and how students see themselves. If real learning depends on human connection and shared effort, where does A.I. fit? Can it help light that spark, or does it risk putting it out?

We have seen this pattern before. Educators have always embraced the latest trends, hoping each one would finally revolutionize the classroom. With social media, we learned a hard lesson about what happens when young people are flooded with an endless, algorithm-driven stream of content.

Students today struggle more than teenagers did in the past. West Hempstead responded, with the help of grants and other initiatives, by expanding social-emotional programs. Those programs matter, but they can’t fully offset the constant pull of the feed. That flood makes it harder for students to stay grounded, ask deep questions and develop the critical, creative and authentic thinking a purposeful, fulfilling life requires. A.I. is the next and more powerful version of the same instant, effortless information. We shouldn’t wait to see how it plays out.

So what does our district want instead? We want forums for debate, not echo chambers. We want reasoned arguments, not instant reactions. We want minds that connect and synthesize knowledge, not passive consumers overwhelmed by complexity.

That means deep literacy and higher-order thinking must come first, because true literacy is higher-order thinking. It means students who can research, reflect and tell fact from fiction. And it means a classroom approach in which, as students get older, they spend more and more time on real-world problem-solving, with teachers acting as mentors and change agents, as education researcher Michael Fullan describes.

To get there, we are forming a task force of students, staff and families to decide together where our district should go with A.I. This isn’t a decision that should be made by a policy written in an office. An algorithm or an isolated administrative mandate can’t capture the messy, interpersonal context where real learning happens. It should come out of the kind of shared, patient conversation I have been describing, the same kind of human spark Plato and Sarason reminded us is irreplaceable.

Of course, I could be wrong. What do you think?

Daniel Rehman is superintendent of the West Hempstead school district.