Columnist

Howard Kopel: Were the good old days really so good?

Posted

“Do not say: ‘How is it that the former days were better than these?’ For you do not ask this out of wisdom.” (Ecclesiastes 7:10)

More and more, I find myself looking back to what now seem to have been simpler and, in many ways, better times. Traditional families, consisting of a father, mother and children and, sometimes, a grandparent or two, were the norm. Popular culture reflected this — just watch reruns of television shows from the 1970s and earlier.

Phones were connected by wire to the wall, and when you came home from work, you left it behind. Tolerance for minorities, while not great, seemed to be steadily improving. The list goes on and on.

But is that really true? Were the “good old days” really better?

Perhaps Ecclesiastes is warning us against the temptation to remember the past as better than it really was.

Obviously, not everything is worse. Living standards have improved dramatically for almost all segments of society. The lives of most lower-middle-class people might make a king of just a few hundred years ago envious. Medical advances have extended lifespans and improved our lives.

But here we are, confronting what seems to be a major societal upheaval. So-called “mostly peaceful” demonstrations, complete with destruction of property and injury to people who might disagree, seem to be de rigueur. Antisemitism has been made to seem respectable by calling it anti-Zionism, and slogans are chanted by young people who have no clue as to what they mean after they have been brainwashed by radical politicians, teachers and professors.

At times it seems that we are witnessing the unraveling of the social fabric. And then I remember something that Ecclesiastes might be trying to tell us: The good old days weren’t always so good while we were living through them.

Those of a certain age will remember the late 1960s and early 1970s as a time of upheaval, marked by protests over the Vietnam War and civil rights, assassinations — Robert F. Kennedy and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. — and even bombings. Colleges were closed mid-semester due to student occupations of facilities and danger to faculty. Things seemed hopeless. There was no way the country could continue on its path. America was doomed!

But gradually, things changed. By the late 1970s, the widespread campus disruptions had largely subsided, and most Americans had returned their attention to the ordinary business of living. As the economist Herbert Stein famously observed, “If something cannot go on forever, it will stop.” And it did.

Events tend to move in cycles for good reason. The country became exhausted by the chaos and backed authorities who cracked down on criminals, and the majority of the country (famously termed by President Richard Nixon as the “Silent Majority”) gave them their strong backing. And, of course, yesterday’s student revolutionaries eventually discovered that mortgages, careers and raising families demanded considerably more attention than occupying the dean’s office.

History doesn’t repeat itself precisely, but neither is every crisis unprecedented. We have lived through periods of turmoil before, and somehow emerged with our country, its institutions and its fundamental freedoms intact. There’s no reason to assume that we can’t do so again.

Perhaps that’s what Ecclesiastes is trying to teach us. The past was never quite as wonderful as we remember it, nor is the present necessarily as hopeless as it sometimes appears. I remain optimistic, not because our problems will somehow solve themselves, but because I’ve seen the good sense and resilience of the American people prevail before. The American experiment has survived far worse than this, and I’m not prepared to bet against it.

Howard Kopel represents Nassau County’s 7th Legislative District and is the Legislature’s presiding officer.